Molina "brought Martone back to this apartment where they stayed for several hours," according to the police report, and everything was fine until she made a remark about being his girlfriend.

When Molina disagreed, "Martone became enraged," said the report. He told her to leave and punched her in the face when she refused to go. She then grabbed a kitchen knife, which they struggled over, and he tossed her outside—where she broke his windows with two big rocks.